Reading results
How should I review an AI flag on a learner's English?
The short answer
Look at the learner's assignment and drafts as you read the flagged passage. A small vocabulary or repeated sentence patterns do not prove AI use. Ask the writer about a concrete choice, then judge the explanation by the same stated rules you apply to other writers.
What the study covered
Liang and colleagues found that the detectors in their 2023 study misclassified many English samples written by nonnative speakers. That result belongs to those tools and those samples. It does not give a current error rate for AiChecker, for every learner or for every language.
Source: Liang et al. (2023): detector bias on nonnative English samples
Return to the exercise
Repeated sentence forms may be the point of a language exercise. Compare the flagged lines with what the learner was asked to practise before drawing a conclusion from the repetition.
Why this example? How was the source used? What changed after feedback? Let the writer explain those choices. The finished wording alone cannot give you that account of the work.
Keep feedback about the language
Comment on clarity and accuracy without asking the learner to roughen the text to suit a score. Any concern belongs in the institution's usual review process, with the writer's response recorded alongside it.